Major Project PodcastProjects over $1B
Episode emails

New episodes, straight to your inbox

One email each time an episode goes out, with the best tips already summarized and a link to the full brief. Unsubscribe any time.

Or follow the show Apple Podcasts Spotify YouTube
Full Transcript · Episode 029

The 20-Year Fight to Build Austin’s Billion-Dollar Transit System

Steve Adler · Former Mayor of Austin Nov 16, 2026 69 min 11 chapters · ~9,700 words
Transcript note Lightly edited machine transcript of the published episode: fillers, false starts and crosstalk trimmed, and four things the transcriber misheard corrected from context and the public record (the book title Hot Seat, Hot City, the agency name CapMetro, the name Mamdani, and the host’s own name once). Speaker labels may still be imperfect. Clocks follow the published video and are approximate. The audio is the record. Listen to the episode · Read the episode brief.
Chapter 01 · 0:00 – ~3:50

The Road In: DC to Austin on a $100 Scholarship

[00:00:00]
Orion Matthews

[00:00:00] Welcome to the Major Project Podcast. I'm your host, Orion Matthews. In this pod, we are learning from the people that work on projects around $1 billion, trying to tease out those lessons and learnings from these big endeavors.

My guest today is former mayor of Austin, Steve Adler, here to talk about Project Connect and the governance, policy, legislation, and community trust side of multi-billion dollar projects. Steve is a rare four-angle guest. So he's worked for 30 years in eminent domain, eight years as chief of staff in the Texas Senate.

He was mayor of Austin from 2013 to 2023 when the city approved the $7.1 billion Project Connect, which we're gonna dive into, and now an educator at the LBJ School, and recently published a memoir a couple months ago called Hot Seat, Hot City. So we've got the academic, courtroom, capital, and city hall perspectives, and an ambitious infrastructure project to learn about.

Steve, welcome to the podcast.

[00:01:01]
Steve Adler

[00:01:00] Orion, thank you for the opportunity to be with you.

[00:01:05]
Orion Matthews

Well, before we get started, can you help us learn a little bit about your history, how you came to Austin and maybe your interest in city infrastructure projects?

[00:01:15]
Steve Adler

Sure. I was born in Washington DC, actually in the city. And that's where I grew up. I went to college outside of New York, in New Jersey at Princeton. And really I came down to Austin and to Texas to go to law school because this was the cheapest law school in the country, and I could afford it. It was back in the day where I think University of Texas was trying to recruit students nationally to build up the reputation of a school that was actually ranked fairly high just because its endowment from oil and gas money was so great.

And they gave me a $100 scholarship, and the importance of a $100 scholarship was you got in-state residency status. [00:02:00] So tuition was $8 an hour, 15-hour semester, cost me 120 bucks. I had a scholarship for $100, so I could afford University of Texas. I came here with no intention of staying. But something funny happened in my time in Austin. I fell in love with the breakfast tacos and the music. You could tell it was a city that was going to grow. There was a feeling of optimism. It was a very creative, welcoming, supportive place.

So I just never left. Infrastructure becomes really key to cities like Austin. I think when I got to Austin, I think we were like the 44th largest city in the country. When I left office, we were probably 10th largest in the country, 10 or 11, and cities just don't make that kind of jump.

Especially in a city like Austin that people just love, but what they love most is the Austin they remember from the first day they were here. [00:03:00] Everybody wants to preserve the city the way that they know it and love it. And for probably a couple decades it was the informal policy of many of the council members not to invest in infrastructure on the very mistaken belief that if you didn't build the infrastructure, people would stop coming.

Doesn't work that way. People come anyhow for all the reasons I did. So we were way behind on infrastructure. Never built out the transportation system, never built out a mass public transit system. We were just behind on so many ways in infrastructure. I grew up with that. I lived that.

When I became mayor, infrastructure investment was one of the highest priorities.

Chapter 02 · ~3:50 – ~6:50

What Austin Said Yes To

[00:03:57]
Orion Matthews

So then this is a good bridge to set the table for us. [00:04:00] What is Project Connect, for those that might not know? What did the Austin voters actually say yes to in November 2020?

[00:04:10]
Steve Adler

In 2020, the Austin voters voted to raise their city property taxes by almost 20% in order to fund mass public transit in the city. I think that city property tax is about 20, 25% of the total property tax load, so really it was about a 4% increase in property taxes generally.

And for that, we raised the money to be able to initiate the building out, first of a small part of, but then to expand over time, a public transit rail component, bus rapid transit (BRT), and other aspects of that system.

[00:05:00] But rather than voting for a bond which is tied to a specific amount usually to raise the money to build the capital components of a project, this was just to raise property taxes indefinitely so as to provide not only for the capital expenditure but for maintenance and operation over time.

[00:05:25]
Orion Matthews

And that was a novel approach, I think. Yeah, maybe let's go talk about the bond a little bit. What was the thinking behind that? What were you trying to avoid, do you think? And what was the idea?

[00:05:41]
Steve Adler

Certainly novel, hadn't been done here in Texas that I'm aware of. Certainly hadn't been done by the city of Austin. But the thinking that we had was, as we looked across the country at a lot of large capital expense projects, cities and communities were successful in getting the money to build them.

[00:06:00] But the cost to operate them became something that became more and more difficult over time. So we wanted to have a funding source and stream that could do both of those things at the time that the voters were voting, so that they would recognize what the cost to them would be, not only of building the project, but maintaining and operating the project.

That meant that it would be built out over time. And we were explaining that, trying to be really transparent about that as we went to voters. But also the fact that this was a significant investment. A 20% increase in property taxes is not something that happens often. And we did it in November of that first COVID year, which made it just that much more difficult.

Chapter 03 · ~6:50 – ~12:20

Twenty Years of No: 2000, the Red Line, 2014

[00:06:58]
Orion Matthews

That's a lot. And then just to back us up a little bit, because I think one thing that'd be interesting to talk about here is the campaign around the proposition. [00:07:00] So a lot of project professionals, they don't oftentimes see what goes into building the proposition, the mechanics of that, setting up the coalition and things like that. How did you actually work with everyone to bring about a yes in November 2020?

[00:07:30]
Steve Adler

We had a lot of history and lessons to go to school on, both here in Austin and in other cities. It was not the first time we were going to the voters with such a proposition. In, it was probably 1999, 2000 frame, there was a mass public transit initiative that went to the voters that was rejected.

And I think it was rejected in large measure by those voices that were saying, "Don't do that in Austin. [00:08:00] It's only going to attract more and more people," and, "Don't we like the city the way that it is? And let's keep it that way." It didn't lose by a lot. It just lost by a few hundred votes.

I think I would have wanted my local government to come back the following year with another vote, tweak the proposal, talk to the voters. They were so close. To be able to come back to the voters right away to say, "Okay, we were close, but we listened to you. We've made these adjustments. Now, this is the package. I think you'll vote." Because if we had voted to approve it back then, and we had initiated the project back then, it would've been so much easier to do before Austin built out another 25 years. It would've been easier to do because the costs were so much lower 25 years ago than they are today.

But that's not what happened. [00:09:00] So instead of that, what the city opted to do four years later was invest money in what we call here locally the Red Line, which was the purchase of an industrial rail right of way that came into downtown Austin. It was the inexpensive way to start providing for public mass transit because it didn't cost as much, so much easier for the political forces to move forward on.

Unfortunately, it didn't go where you would put a public mass transit line. The line was already placed, and it wasn't placed with attracting the greatest ridership as possible.

Unfortunate then because our one example of mass public transit, this Red Line, never really achieved the kinds of usage or adoption that you would have wanted it to.

It never really hit where most potential riders were. [00:10:00] It started in the way northwest, kind of came to middle city, went way over to the east of the city, and then came in downtown, but really missing that development corridor in the center of town. So rather than having a wonderful briefcase to show our community, we had something that for the next 20 years we were always trying to explain away as not being an example of what it was that we would do.

There were several attempts over the next couple of decades to correct what I think was the error of the council back in 2000. Because the mayor and the council really should have gone back then. They didn't. They did the Red Line, not the smartest move. Nothing actually got the momentum.

When I came into office in 2015, I think the city cumulatively had done $650 million in capital projects, transportation projects over the prior 20 years. [00:11:00] But anyhow, so in 2014 when I was running for mayor, there was also a proposition on the ballot. The mayor then stepped out just before me and said, "Let's get something passed." It was a proposal, it came late. It was never really vetted or developed by the community. It was changing in the spring prior to the election, and it just never really stood a chance.

I can remember looking at that project, and I think this is insightful for people trying to go to school on Austin's history. I can remember waking up one morning and looking at the newspaper in the morning as Diane and I were drinking our coffee, and on the front page of the newspaper was a design of the route that was gonna go before the voters, and it showed just that partial route that would actually get initial funding, and it went from point A to point B.

[00:12:00] And it was not a very long route, and it didn't connect to anything. It was just there. And I turned to Diane and I said, "The election's over," because 98% of the city looked at that sketch and said, "That doesn't concern me."

Chapter 04 · ~12:20 – ~14:30

The Metro Map Lesson

[00:12:21]
Steve Adler

I remember growing up in Washington, DC, back when they initiated Metro. I remember the first time I saw drawings of Metro, it was the complete system. It went everywhere, and it reached way out into everywhere, and it hit everywhere. Now, a lot of that was marked on there, if you read the print, wasn't gonna happen for 40 years.

But everybody was okay with that, so long as that map showed that they were at least part of the design, a part of the vision. They could wait until it got to them, as long as they weren't ignored.

[00:13:00] This drawing on the front page of the newspaper didn't see anybody. It was, I think, the engineer's answer to what are the voters going to approve. And by the way, all we can do is what's in bold color.

So we had the election in 2014. I think there were probably, I don't know, 70 or 80 local candidates for local office, city council, and mayor, because we were changing the form of government at that point from an at-large system to a district system.

And of the 70 to 80 candidates running, I think only two of them supported that proposition. So everybody was running, rallying against it. I was one of two, but even I knew that it wasn't going to pass. So I ran, as I was running in 2014, saying we need a public mass transit system for lots of reasons, to provide real access and opportunity for people in our community who were being held back by limited transportation options, by the cost associated with having to be so dependent on single family, single-user cars.

[00:14:00] And not to mention the land use and development kinds of things, the help with density and all the things that come with doing this kind of project. I said, "We need this, but I recognize this is not the plan that people are going to want, so I promise before I leave office to bring something back to the community that it will be able to support."

Chapter 05 · ~14:30 – ~19:20

Six Years of Groundwork

[00:14:37]
Steve Adler

And six years later, after I got elected, so six years and two years into my second term, that's what we did. There was a lot that went into that campaign to ensure that campaign would be successful. First off, over that six-year period of time, there were thousands of community meetings.

[00:15:00] What do you want this system to be? Where should it go? What are the benefits of having it? What are the trade-offs in having it? Pretty much anybody who would stand up and raise their hand at the time the election took place was pulled into or made part of that process. The other thing that happened was that CapMetro, which was our bus system, really did a lot of work on building goodwill in the community.

Started really focusing on being much more consumer-centered and responsive, much more in terms of being transparent. But also had a campaign to let people know about CapMetro. This was an organization that nearly went bankrupt, nearly taken over by the state five, 10 years earlier, had a really bad reputation.

[00:16:00] But we knew that if it came time to a vote it would in part be a referendum on how people felt about CapMetro. So a lot of that time was spent. We looked at the kinds of activities that happened in areas like Denver, where they formed citizen transportation advocacy groups that pulled together organizations outside of government to build a booster group, as it was.

And we built that booster group over that period of time, so we had advocates outside of government that were pushing for these things. We also watched what happened in Nashville. And there were a couple lessons that we learned from that. Nashville went a couple years ahead of us with a proposal that I thought was a really good proposal.

It was defeated by the voters. They lost their mayor in the middle of that election. The mayor had to resign because some issues arose, which was really unfortunate because she was the face and the embodiment of the project. [00:17:00] So we recognized the importance that individual validators would have, and tried to turn that back story into something that would be really positive, because we recognized that.

Tire warriors, the road warriors folks associated, I think, in that election with the Koch brothers, more conservative approach to transportation issues, that were able to get as their spokesman someone from the Black community who raised questions about the equity involved in the proposal. What was really hard about that was it divided the community in Nashville that should have been a community that was 100%, or near 100%, or overwhelmingly supportive of the project, and made things confused such that people who showed up at the polls were trying to figure out, "So what is the right choice if I want to cast a progressive vote in this progressive city? [00:18:00] Which one is the progressive vote? I'm uncertain about that."

We spent a lot of time trying to identify those people that were leaders of or involved in organizations that were real prime recipients of the benefits of the program, involved them in the actual routing and decisions to be made so that there was a lot of buy-in.

I think that the stations that we had designed and would be eventually part of Project Connect, 75% of the affordable housing in our city was within a walkshed of stations for the line. And then things like that got built into the project. [00:19:00] So we just tried to spend a lot of time invested upfront, both in engineering decisions and in political decisions, so that when we did take it to the voters, we knew we had something that people would support.

And even though it was a 20% increase in property taxes, it passed with 58% of the vote in November of 2020. We were very proud of that.

Chapter 06 · ~19:20 – ~27:00

Designing for the Vote: Chamber, Equity and the Big Number

[00:19:28]
Orion Matthews

Yeah, congratulations on that. It's a great story on how to get something passed. And one thing that I wanna dial into, because we have a lot of listeners here that are on the commercial side, so they're building floating offshore things.

They have a community engagement team that's maybe five people or two, and they've got a little Excel file that's like permits. And then what you're sharing is the story of community engagement with thousands of conversations, bringing along a whole coalition. [00:20:00] And I think one thing I'm curious to explore here is the commercial side. I think they want to have a solid impact on the community, and a good impact. I think there are honest actors trying to do that. And then I think when communities go to build things, they are 95% focused on the community, and then they've got this sort of thinking about the commercial side of the people that are gonna do it.

And so what I'm curious about is, during that process, how did you bring along the commercial interests and get them involved? Or do you wait for that until you get the money and then start working with those folks that are gonna do the building?

And maybe this ties into the Austin Transit Partnership that we could talk a little bit about, because that's a unique entity model for how you actually got the project started.

[00:21:05]
Steve Adler

[00:21:00] I don't think you can wait, because I think that even the initial threshold decisions for how you approach them, how you deal with them, everything is building toward that vote.

And you're trying to build the best project you can, and you need to do that, but you have to build the best project with an eye to someone's gonna vote on this at the end. So there really shouldn't be very many engineering decisions that are not informed by what that eventual glide path is going to look like.

In fact, I probably should leave out the word eventual. The glide path starts with the initial work. Now, we had been through two elections where this concept had failed, both in 2000 and again in 2014. So I think we were hyper cognizant of the fact that none of this work was gonna go anywhere if we couldn't get the vote. [00:22:00] So people started working together at the very beginning in terms of the routing decisions and where the stations would be. And there are certain engineering questions and ridership questions that are mostly objective or at least an accepted way on how to measure or predict that.

But to have somebody at the very first meeting that's saying, "And what percentage of the affordable housing in the city is within a walkshed of what you've drawn?" is a question that oftentimes with engineers doesn't come up early enough in the process. And then people are trying to tweak a plan, deliver as much of that as they can, as opposed to building it into the plan. We'd also learned, and I think this is an important lesson for people that are approaching big projects. [00:23:00] Big projects scare people because they're a lot of money. In Austin, I think it was probably 2011 or thereabouts, our city council took to the voters an affordable housing bond, $80 million.

Big project, $80 million is a lot of money. Affordable housing, there were just not a history of bond elections for affordable housing. Went to the voters and the voters rejected it. The city council lesson that they took from that was that they had asked for too much money. So they came back a year or two later, affordable housing bond proposal, $60 million, and it passed.

My read from watching those elections, not as a city person, quite frankly, as just somebody in the community who had never thought about nor ever anticipated actually running for any elected office, was that was not the lesson to be learned from that.

[00:24:00] I think that people were having trouble with the 60 or $80 million bond proposition, both, because neither was really big enough to move voters into thinking something transformational would be happening in their city. And what makes people vote for big things or big dreams are the belief that government's going to do something that will change the trajectory of the city.

That's what people want. Most elections that we're seeing in today's world are change elections. Nobody likes the status quo at any point in time, so everyone's always looking for change. That's what inspires people and energizes people. In our first bond election after I got elected, we went to the voters with a transportation infrastructure type proposition.

[00:25:00] We had just had the votes on affordable housing. And I suggested to my city council that we do something that was $700 million, which was very close to cumulatively, as I said earlier, what we had. And they all looked at me like I was crazy. And several of them announced at that point they would support me, but nothing over $100 million.

That would be, like, the limit. We worked that really hard, and it was touch and go. Eventually, we went to the voters with a $720 million transportation bond. And it included active transportation, it included making smarter use of existing right of way. That was the thrust of it. It was the first election we had like that was not centered on new roads or widening existing roads to increase at least an interim capacity on those roads.

[00:26:00] And it passed overwhelmingly. People were really excited about it. We went back to our voters every two years thereafter with a bond proposition, painting vision and a kind of mission, that kind of Austin exceptionalism, building into how people felt pride in their community and what it could be.

And I think that's a really important lesson for people to have that are doing big projects, and we approached Project Connect that way. It had to be something that the community saw as being transformative, visionary, out of the ordinary. And then we thought people would support it. They would trust the government to handle the logistics of it, but they would vote for that because they wanted that vision.

Chapter 07 · ~27:00 – ~33:30

The Third Leg: Austin Transit Partnership

[00:27:04]
Steve Adler

[00:27:00] So one of the things that we set up, and to answer your question on ATP, is we got involved very early, the chamber, so that we would have business support for doing the road, recognizing it was going to involve a property tax increase, which is something the chamber loathed to support.

And out of those conversations with them, they expressed concerns about having the city council manage a $7 billion project. They were afraid of cost overruns and delays and how contracts would be awarded. They felt a lot more comfortable when we said, "What if we empower a group that is technocrats?"

And they formed the third leg of the stool, city council, CapMetro, and this Austin Transportation Partnership that would actually be the entity that would get the funding from the bonds to build the road, and there would be an engineer on it and an accountant on it. [00:28:00] And in addition to a community activist and representative, five people, including a city representative and a CapMetro representative, to try to de-politicize the choices.

And let's agree for a constitution or bylaws for that organization and how the city and the county would operate, and how we try to take out politics so we can best do this objectively. And it was only because we built in that layer that we ended up getting the chamber support for the project, just barely.

But if we hadn't done that, we wouldn't have been close. So we had now a structure that came out of, and that's something baked in relatively early, in order to keep chamber support through the process while we were building out the project. [00:29:00] We had the businesses that were signing up saying that the chamber was involved, but now we're signing up for that community booster group for transportation projects. We brought in all the social activists, the equity activists in our community and included elements in the proposal that might not ordinarily be part of a transportation bond.

A couple hundred million dollars just to be spent on affordable housing at stations, to be able to buy up land around the stations before the prices escalated and the like, so we could build out the kind of affordable housing that the community wanted to see. At that point, that was the largest affordable housing bond we'd ever done, or spending approval that we'd gotten from voters, and it was inside of a transportation initiative.

And when people went eventually to vote on Project Connect, they were voting for that $200 million in affordable housing support. [00:30:00] It was built into the mission and into the bond language, or the proposition language, that went before the voters. To your question, I think that it's really important to build, especially on a project of this size, that coalition as broadly as you can, because there will be people that step up to oppose it. Their argument's always appealing in terms of keeping property taxes low.

The argument that transportation projects never pay for themselves will always be there, because by and large they don't. Either do our streets and our roads, but we never make that same kind of direct kind of comparison. But there will be opposition, and you need to have a team in place that's going to be able to deal with that opposition when it arises.

[00:31:04]
Orion Matthews

[00:31:00] And I harken back, because I lived in DC as well, my daughter was born there actually, and I think about what an impact that Metro system has had on the city. It's really changed the way that the city functions in intangible ways. So you can look at the cost, but DC would not be the same without their Metro system, and I think of that for many cities that you visit.

London, or any city that has a really well-structured, functioning infrastructure around transportation, has so many more benefits than just the dollar amount per rider that you're measuring or something like that. Just real quick, on Austin Transit Partnership, what's your greatest takeaway on that for good, and perhaps for do differently next time, for a model like that?

[00:32:01]
Steve Adler

[00:32:00] I think that what's good about it, I think, is the point people in charge of executing the project are more technical people, and because they're not the city council, are a little bit more removed from the politics that ordinarily come with these large projects. And I think it's important on lots of levels to separate those as best you can.

Not totally, because obviously the city council can assert its will in the process. It's just more difficult. And it involves CapMetro, so more difficult. So anything that's big and has to happen can still happen, but kind of incidental meddling, the kinds of things that sometimes happen in a political process, you're farther removed from.

That's an advantage and a disadvantage. [00:33:00] The leadership of the ATP, less known by the public. Probably there's a feeling that it's less transparent because it's a little bit farther away. So it has to work hard to be perceived as being not a black hole, as being really transparent, and just putting your meetings on the web so that people can live stream it is not the same thing as forcing a presence. But jury's still out to see how that works.

Chapter 08 · ~33:30 – ~39:30

Costs Explode, the Levy Holds, and the Contract with Voters

[00:33:35]
Steve Adler

We were really excited to be able to pass it in November of 2020. I think ours was the only major project to get approved, that I'm aware of, in that timeframe.

But almost immediately what happened is that supply chain issues started dramatically increasing costs.

Cost of glass went up 800%. Everything costs went way up, as did the cost for this project. [00:34:00] And many projects around the country that had been approved in elections authorizing bonds to be issued found themselves in the position where they could issue the bonds and couldn't come close to the project, so the project was canceled despite a favorable vote in their community because as costs went up, it just wasn't enough money anymore.

In our situation, we were not getting approval for a specific dollar amount. We were getting approved for an annual levy, which meant that we could still raise all the money we had anticipated raising. It might just take us 15 more years. It would take us a longer time to raise the amount of money that we wanted to raise.

In our case, the project's been pulled back, at least the initial phase of it. We lost some elements that I really liked, like going underground downtown. It's now going to be above ground like in Indianapolis, which is still a wonderful system. [00:35:00] But we lost some of those elements in order to be able to do as much as we could in that first phase.

I still believe in the project. I still hope all the phases are eventually done. Obviously, it's changed a little bit and will take more time.

[00:35:19]
Orion Matthews

Estimates aren't exact, right? So it came to the voters at 5% design. How do you politically handle that conversation around the uncertainty when you're dealing with the public?

[00:35:36]
Steve Adler

It's hard. Hard because there are so many changes that happen after 5% drawing as you get in and you learn more, and where the utility lines are, or you get some more information, and the engineering changes.

And some of the engineering changes that have to be made, especially when you're looking at tunneling under the Colorado River, you're looking at a lot of things that could be thrown way off as you get past 5%. [00:36:00] Same time, it's really expensive to go past 5%. It costs money to get to 20, 25% drawings.

And I'm not sure it's responsible for a government to invest what it costs to go from 5% to 20 or 25% without the voters saying, "Yeah, that's a direction that we want to head," especially in a city like Austin, where the voters twice have said, "We don't want to go that way." So you're caught between a rock and a hard place.

Do you do the 5% and then present your best available information to the community, or do you spend the money to get greater certainty and then go to the community, but then answer all the questions about why you were spending that much money without the community telling you you should proceed? That challenge became so much more difficult for this project in this timing because it was unprecedented changes in the cost of supplies as we've seen over the last eight years.

[00:37:00] We just have never seen anything like this. And we were caught on that. When we took the issue to the voters, we explained to the voters it was a really high dollar amount. We also made the citizens aware that we were counting on federal funding for half of it, relations with the Department of Transportation, and there was nothing guaranteed about that. But we also talked about that with the community. We even talked about what happens if, say, the federal funding never came through. When we did the election for the voters, the city council drafted a contract with voters that said, "This is how we're thinking about this project and this vote and what we'll do and won't do."

[00:38:00] We passed it as a contract with the voters. It becomes part of the bond or the vote package that I think citizens would have a right to sue on if the council was changing in ways that they had represented otherwise. But one of the specific provisions said we're going after federal funding to build this.

If the federal funding does not materialize, if it doesn't happen, then, and at that point we could have said, "We'll come back to the voters." We could have said, "We're not gonna be able to build the project, we'll cancel the project." But we didn't say either of those things. We said, "We'll build however much of the project as we can."

And we'll continue to do that. So that's what we're gonna do. We're gonna build public mass transit, and we'll build as much of it as we can, as fast as we can, in a way that does justice to having a public mass transit system. [00:39:00] So we provided for that in our vote, in our build up to the vote with the community.

And I think that level of transparency and disclosure enables there to be a meeting of minds that hopefully would help you avoid litigation. Doesn't always work that way, but I think it'll help in that case.

Chapter 09 · ~39:30 – ~42:30

Holding the Coalition When the Scope Shrinks

[00:39:31]
Orion Matthews

And as the project sort of scales back, like you said, have to adjust for the new world, how do you keep the coalition together? Do you have a little bit of a story to share about, and lessons around, right-sizing your project with the public and with the commercial side, and in general? How do you do that? How do you land that airplane?

[00:39:54]
Steve Adler

I think it's a question of being really diligent and really active.

The core people that were supporting this project were supporting this project for reasons that are just as true with the changed phasing or changed scope, just as true. [00:40:00] We still need public mass transit for all the reasons we needed it before. It will still help with accessibility and equity in a community. All those things are true. There were some people that just really wanted to have an underground metro like in Washington, DC, that they saw. And some of those people you're going to lose because they weren't supporting it for the base fundamental reasons.

They were supporting because they wanted to be able to shop in a mall underground like they can do in Washington, DC. You'll lose some of those people. The project initially was going out to the airport as one of its terminus points. It surprises me how much print and space that extension to the airport gets, because I think everybody who never sees themselves on public mass transit in their day-to-day activities think they'll take it out to the airport maybe.

[00:41:00] When you actually run the numbers, it's really not the numbers that you would need to be able to really pay for or generate the line the same way the stretch downtown will be with people going from North Central to downtown and back to North Central again. But when you take something like that off the plan, again, it's a deflating thing for some people.

So I think you, one, try to hold your coalition together. Second, you make sure that in the room where decisions are being made, where people are making choices about what can happen or not happen, it is not just engineers, not just people that are working off of the objective fact, because you still need public support.

[00:42:00] So just like putting together your campaign and designing your project, being cognizant at the very beginning that it's eventually gonna have to go to voters, the decisions that you make, even if there is an absolutely correct engineering decision to be made, has a lot of weight, but it's not controlling.

Neither is the political answer necessarily controlling. But those two points of view have to lock themselves in a room long enough to work through those kinds of issues.

Chapter 10 · ~42:30 – ~51:20

The Numbers Came Late

[00:42:35]
Orion Matthews

That's great insight. Do you think that perhaps we don't have, is there an option in other cities or states where, Texas has so many construction firms, and just, was there a point in time where you said, "Okay, we gotta get this done for 7.1. [00:43:00] Maybe we just need to cut through whoever these people are giving us these quotes and figure out a different one. There's gotta be some group out there that's willing to get this done for this amount of money," or was it just an impossibility when you looked at the hard facts?

Because I feel like there's a lot of padding in construction. How do you squeeze all that out or navigate that? Because it just must be really frustrating to get these numbers back, and do we have not enough competition, or do you think it was just the hard reality of concrete costing X?

[00:43:36]
Steve Adler

I was mayor up until early 2023. And we had the project approved at that point. The money was coming in. We had actually started funding the higher percent levels of design work. We had already put money aside for purchasing of affordable housing property based on the early returns coming in. [00:44:00] But I was not there at the time that they started awarding the really large contracts.

The people that were advising us at that time were the consultants who are the project side consultants, who I hope were doing all of those things to help us understand what the cost should be. But I think you're raising a really good point, and I think it became apparent even while I was mayor that this project was gonna cost a lot more than what we had anticipated, and it was gonna require pretty substantial changes in scope or timing.

And I think that one of the lessons learned was that the engineers and the folks on that side didn't disclose that information to the political leaders as quickly as they realized it, trying to work through and trying to solve those questions before there was any kind of political disclosure.

[00:45:00] And sitting on the political side of that, I wish I had gotten that information six months earlier, eight months earlier, because it could have changed the way that I talked about the future of the project, even if I wasn't explicit in why at that point, because we were uncertain as to what was true or what was not true.

That would've been really helpful information for me. But that disconnect existed. But from a contracting standpoint, you're stewards, trustees of the public coffers, and you wanna do everything you can. I look at the cost per mile of doing a project in this country versus doing a project elsewhere.

There were some studies that were done on that, and I can't remember the source, the study came out in probably 2021, 2022, that did that kind of comparison. And a lot of times it was the delays, it was changes in scope, scope creep. [00:46:00] It was litigation. Some of those things probably you find more of in this country because generally government operates at a more transparent level.

Court system is more available to more people. So I think there's some justification for that at a high level, but it's absolutely imperative that our governments figure out the way to build the best projects for the least amount of money.

[00:46:39]
Orion Matthews

But I'm curious what you think might be there, because I think, like you said, Americans have an appetite to do big things. I would love to channel some of your eminent domain knowledge here perhaps on this. Is there a certain configuration that makes it harder for us, cost per mile perhaps? I think in your book you were talking about how the people's biggest investment is their home, and things that impact their home, whether you're building a big project around it or stuff, it's their biggest asset, and a lot of their hopes are tied into that.

[00:47:00] So when you're talking infrastructure, you're touching this core nerve of American psyche around doing big things, and then also their entire financial position and possibly their future. So you have these two things in balance, and then you have eminent domain laws layered on top of that. I'm just curious if some of that configuration causes additional cost here in this country versus others, or if you have other insights that might be driving that.

[00:47:42]
Steve Adler

I think that the laws have been written in this country to provide property owners a more equitable outcome than our eminent domain laws in many other places. Many other places, property's being taken from you for a project, for example, but it enhances your remaining property. [00:48:00] The government can offset that increase against the damages they would otherwise pay. Some jurisdictions, that's true in the United States, other jurisdictions not.

In some jurisdictions in Europe and other places, the condemning authority is allowed to acquire property in the front of its projects because it knows it's going to enhance value that it can then bank and then sell in order to raise revenue to help build the project.

Not so much in this country.

I am reminded of a story. Before I was mayor, before that thought had ever crossed my mind, I was a tiny investor in a real estate project in China because I thought it would give me an excuse to figure out a way to get to China to learn more about that country. [00:49:00] And sure enough, I went to China with this investor group on this multifamily project.

And we were at dinner one night, and our council attorney in China and I were sitting next to each other at dinner, and at one point she looked at me and asked me what kind of law I practiced. I told her I'd done civil rights law, but now was really focused on eminent domain work.

And she said, "What happens if you win?" to me. And I said, "I'm not exactly sure what you're asking. If I win, then my client gets paid a fair amount for the property that's being taken for the project." And she looked at me and she said, "No, no, no, no. What happens to you if you win?" [00:50:00] was her question.

Which I found to be very telling, that the outcome of the case, how successful you were in getting justice for your client, might be a conflict in interest, and whether as an attorney you actually wanted to do well by your client or not. Her concern was whether there's retribution against you as an attorney if you are a successful advocate.

So I would imagine that maybe there are some of those influences at play that are part of those many other variables that I listed a second ago for why costs might be higher here. But it is significantly higher cost. And somebody other than me, just guessing where you and I are talking, really needs to understand that better so as to minimize that as best we can.

It's just big capital projects happen in China and in Asia just so much more quickly and rapidly than they do here. [00:51:00] I was just in Korea and riding on their public mass transit system, which happens so fast, and it's such a wonderful system, much of it underground, that really does make you wonder about whether this country can be competitive so long as we can't deliver that same way.

Chapter 11 · ~51:20 – 1:09:09

Trust, Advice and the Book

[00:51:28]
Orion Matthews

So if you're thinking about other mayors that might be listening to this podcast, and you've had this wonderful history, do you have some advice for them then? What are some green flags for a project? What are some red flags to be considering? What's your advice?

[00:51:47]
Steve Adler

They should get my book and read it, number one. That's about the city. I write about a lot of things that all those mayors are going to recognize and understand, or understand even intuitively. [00:52:00] But I think one of the big lessons over my eight years is just recognizing the value of trust. People will give benefit of the doubt and support to people that they trust, elected leaders that they trust, even without knowing the particulars.

People trust those that they think are on their team and will operate for them. And it's hard to understate the value of that measure of trust. People will even give you the benefit of the doubt and support you when you do something they don't like, if they believe that you were at least acting in a deliberate way and were weighing consequences, heard and did not ignore their point of view.

[00:53:00] Even if you ultimately disagree, "I know you wanted me to vote this way, I didn't vote this way, but let me tell you why I didn't vote this way", that will still leave you in good standing with most people. So I think that's really important for leaders at all levels to understand. In some ways you see that with the president and with the core base that he has, even as he hemorrhages trust outside of his core.

But that dichotomy, I think, provides a really good example. So being transparent and being open, being authentic and being real, letting people know that you hear what they're saying, and beyond hearing it, that it actually was taken into account and played a role in what you were trying to do.

[00:54:00] I got in trouble most when I tried to shortcut that. And government is not easy because sometimes if what you're trying to do is to break inertia, to really bring about much needed but difficult to achieve institutional change, sometimes you need to act fast before you're able to gain all the support you need.

Sometimes the old expression is that change happens at the speed of trust. Sometimes change has to happen more quickly than that if you're actually going to make things change. Some things don't change with incremental changes. So I can argue both. Without incremental change, you don't have lasting change.

I can argue both sides of those questions, which is why I know political leaders are often in hot seats, because there's not a clear answer as to in any given situation what's right, other than to make sure that the choices that you're making in that regard are deliberate, that there is time when you sit down and say, "Do I move fast or do I move slow?

[00:55:00] What are the repercussions of moving fast? What are the benefits of moving fast? What are the repercussions and benefits of moving more slowly?" Make the best decision that you can and make it work, but just don't let that decision be made for you. Always deliberately make that decision as best you can.

[00:55:50]
Orion Matthews

Great advice. Trust. What would you say to the engineers, the project controllers, the risk managers of the world? Do you have a piece of advice for them from the political side?

[00:56:06]
Steve Adler

[00:56:00] Just that political considerations are as important for engineers as engineers want engineering considerations to be important to politicians.

And nobody on either side of that equation really believes that, or believes that to the degree where they institutionalize that or where they prioritize it the same, just because surgeons like to operate to fix problems because that's what they know. And that, of course, is pretty general statement, and there are exceptions, just as there are engineers who have an uncanny political compass, and politicians that really understand the practical implications of what it is that they want to achieve or what they want to avoid.

[00:57:00] But it's really recognizing that there is no such thing as an engineering solution that does not include politics, just as there's no correct political choice that does not hold on to engineering constraints and opportunities.

[00:57:32]
Orion Matthews

Well said. And then just moving down the list, what advice would you give to students?

I think you're educating new generation right now, but I think a lot of people from the COVID era actually have an idea that major change could occur, that they could be a part of that. And if there's a student listening that's interested in getting something big done, what advice would you give them?

[00:58:00]
Steve Adler

[00:58:00] I am so energized and excited by the interactions I have with students. And I'm on three campuses. All student bodies different, but all equally hope-building. And I think part of it is that the world is different for this new generation. Not only have they seen such change so as to make the possibility of change much more real than it was for you, and certainly for me, where big things just never happened, or it felt that way.

This generation now of students are watching so much change, and not only so much change, but so much change so rapidly. The speed at which change happens is just incredible. [00:59:00] So for students I would make sure that they recognize the uniqueness of the time that they live in.

Of course, as in the theory of relativity, they're riding on that train, so they might not understand that speed in the same way that people who are not on that train are seeing that fast train move on the tracks from outside.

Everybody has to decide what's important. Is making money important? Is making your community important? Is your relationship with your kids or your partner important? What is it that is really important? And I would center that in the decisions that they make as they're seeking change.

Because I think sometimes change is happening and can be intoxicating, and some of the people that get involved in change begin to lose sight of those foundational supports that undergird, or should support and direct, the decisions that we make. [01:00:00] And we live in a day and age where I think for many people it's becoming easier and easier to divorce those two things.

And as somebody who's later in life, as I look back and evaluate my time, as I watch and try to figure out, like everybody else, what's going on today, the importance of grounding yourself in the things that you believe are important is just that much more necessary.

[01:00:50]
Orion Matthews

Great advice. Maybe you could give us, as we wrap up, a little bit of people that might be interesting to follow that you found helpful during the process of Project Connect, any books that you wish you had read or that you did read, and perhaps tell us a little bit about your book. [01:01:00] But what kind of takeaways or things can we turn people onto to help broaden their horizons around these big endeavors?

[01:01:16]
Steve Adler

There are a lot of people that are out there now. And if I was someone looking for books on understanding, I think I would generally cheat toward folks that were younger that were going to be really the policymakers and the leaders coming up. I'm a big fan of Secretary Buttigieg, and was when he was mayor of South Bend, and I watched what he was doing in that relatively small community that were innovative and creative as concerns capital projects, not only transportation projects, but water, sewer infrastructure, which was a huge issue where he was.

[01:02:00] And then his time as Secretary of Transportation and being the key person to work at the intersection of engineering and politics and getting a bipartisan infrastructure bill passed. So I'd be looking at people like him. I'd be looking at leaders like Mamdani in New York whose approach to infrastructure comes from a little bit different place, and the solutions he reaches to first are a little bit different kinds of solutions.

And I think there's much to support from both of those folks. And politically they're just really different. But there's a whole cadre of young mayors and municipal leaders that are doing great things in Los Angeles and Cincinnati and Cleveland.

And I pay real close attention to some of the municipal leaders. [01:03:00] I believe in local government. I believe in the government that's really closest to the people. I think that's where innovation is incubated. So I would be spending time there. In the eight years I was mayor, I'm not sure that I had a chance to read any kind of popular book.

I'm like eight behind on the novels I wanna read. There's a big pile next to my bed. Almost all the books that you can see behind me out of focus are city policy books and planning books, and there's no absence of those in terms of cities and idea cities and growth cities and just policy and different approaches to housing.

There's just so much to learn. I'm not sure anybody has really the right formula. And really you only come up with a sense of your direction and getting exposed to the plus and minuses of so many different views, which is a point I tried to make in my book. [01:04:00] So my book is about my eight years in office.

And mostly it's chapters each devoted to a different kind of policy issue, one on race, one on zoning, two chapters on homelessness, one on emergency with COVID, and a chapter on dealing with the anonymous bomber that was killing people in our community, with an eye to trying to take issues that the public doesn't really understand.

Because in today's partisan divided world, those policy arguments so quickly get reduced to caricatures of what's really at issue. On any of these controversial issues, if your belief is that your side is 100% right and the other side is 100% wrong, then you have work to do, because there is no hard issue where that's true. [01:05:00] Both sides of hard issues have some valid arguments, or they wouldn't be hard issues.

You could believe in your resolution 100%, but it's important to be able to recognize, even in that moment when you're 100% certain as to the right way to go, the ability to be able to say, "And I'm doing that despite the fact that this was a decent argument the other side had." People don't do that enough.

They don't understand that enough. And if people could do that, number one, they would be better advocates for the position that they are taking. Second, it would be harder for them to demonize someone who didn't come to the same conclusion that they came to, if you allow that there's actually some basis for something that person does believe.

[01:06:13]
Orion Matthews

[01:06:00] I do think that binary thinking, as you're saying it, seems to be something we need to figure a way to break out of, because perhaps the pendulum has swung pretty binary these days, maybe as a result of the way we're getting media, maybe as just trends of the day. But perhaps that's a really great thing for us all to work on and hopefully dig our way out of, to be a little more nuanced.

[01:06:40]
Steve Adler

I think that's true. It's obviously a challenge the whole country faces at this point in time.

[01:06:46]
Orion Matthews

Before we wrap up, what's the single most salient thing you hope someone might take away from our chat today?

[01:06:55]
Steve Adler

There are two things. The first is the importance of trust and to really think about how you build that and how you use that in constructive ways. [01:07:00] Because the flip side of that is misinformation and fear which is the darker side of the positive aspects of trust.

And then the other belief that people need to believe in government. When I think about local government, I was always frustrated with people that thought of local government as something that happened to them, this thing out there that did stuff to them. I think it's a better way to characterize local government as a group of families getting together to try to do something that any one family can't do alone.

That's what local government is. It's just the families getting together to do that. And when you look at it that way, you give greater grace to your neighbors than you do to your government, unless they're the same thing. [01:08:00] And you recognize the importance of inspiration and vision and hope, because that's what drives us as individuals and as families, and should be the well that local government goes to.

[01:08:25]
Orion Matthews

And if the audience wants to find out more about what you're doing, connect with you, learn more, obviously your book and then how else could they maybe follow along?

[01:08:36]
Steve Adler

Go to mayoradler.com. And there's a way to contact and email me directly on that site.

[01:08:44]
Orion Matthews

Thank you so much for taking the time to join us today. I know I've learned a ton about the governance side of mega projects. Appreciate you taking us through this really large initiative and being so candid with your thoughts and sharing your stories.

[01:08:59]
Steve Adler

Absolutely, Orion. [01:09:00] Thanks for doing this podcast on this issue because it's so critical to our cities and to our country. Thanks for having me on.